Re: Tool Decission Dilema (Contest)
Hi Dan, and welcome!
There is no one tool that can do EVERYTHING. However, the classic comes mighty close, for most purposes.
I first started the pneumatic phase of my career with one of Steve's early tools. It has a stroke adjustment, but it is inside the tool. You had to take the graver out, loosen a set screw, and then adjust the stroke length. For most work, I just left it alone. Even now, using a classic, I seldom adjust the stroke length, but it is much more convenient. To get the lightest or heaviest cuts though, the stroke adjustment really is necessary.
If price is truly an issue, and at some point, it is, the Artisan will likely serve you well for a lifetime of use. If you get to the point that you could control the lightest settings on the classic, you could probably hand push with the Artisan, and get similar results. If you find the top end not heavy enough, you can usually get the depth and width of cut with multiple passes of the artisan and the heavy piston.
The proof of my point? Look at some high end work done with hammer and chisel and by hand pushing. The Artisan will get you close, and the rest you will have to figure out. It can be done.The Classic will get you the whole way, assuming you keep after it. For the long haul.
If saving for the Classic will delay your tool purchase by a year or more, I would get the Artisan, and get going. If you could save the difference in 6 months or so, I would wait and get the Classic, and keep drawing in the meantime, and sharpen some tools and try some hand pushing while you are waiting.
BTW, Yes, Steve's tools are the best, and worth every penny you spend. They will not make you a great engraver though. You will have to find that in your own heart.
All the best,
Tom
|